• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Steve's Sizzling Steaks

In the heart of Carlstadt, NJ, Steve's Sizzling Steaks stands out as a go-to spot for steak lovers. Offering a variety of sizzling entrees like the Cowboy Steak and Filet Mignon, this steakhouse also caters to those with dietary preferences with Vegan and Keto options. With a casual yet classy ambiance, this restaurant provides a welcoming atmosphere for groups and families alike. From the Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail to the Chicken Salad, each dish is prepared with precision and flavor. With amenities like outdoor seating, full bar, and free Wi-Fi, Steve's Sizzling Steaks ensures a memorable dining experience for all.

LOCATIONS
  • Steve's Sizzling Steaks
    620 State Rt 17 Carlstadt, NJ 07072
    620 State Rt 17 Carlstadt, NJ 07072 Hotline: (201) 438-9677

Welcome to Steve's Sizzling Steaks, where your steak cravings meet the perfect sizzle! Nestled along State Route 17 in Carlstadt, NJ, this esteemed steakhouse has crafted a reputation that tantalizes taste buds and warms hearts. With a menu boasting succulent steaks, including the renowned Filet Mignon and the meaty Cowboy Steak, Steve’s is a haven for steak lovers seeking top-notch quality and flavor.

The experience begins as soon as you step inside. While some have noted that the interior may exude a bit of an old-world charm, it's the food that truly steals the show. The moment you take a bite of the filet mignon, as praised by satisfied diners like Chris K. and Debbie C., you’ll find that it’s not just a meal; it’s an experience. Tender, perfectly cooked, and bursting with flavor, it’s no wonder why patrons proclaim it to be the best steak they’ve ever had.

But the journey doesn’t end there. The offerings at Steve's extend beyond just stellar steaks. Start your meal with the Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail or indulge in the crispy Breaded Fried Shrimp, served with zesty cocktail sauce—perfect for whetting your appetite. Accompany your main courses with delightful sides like golden French Fries or rich Creamed Spinach, each ensuring that every bite is a pleasure.

As you enjoy your meal, the attentive service will make you feel right at home. Diners like Sean C. appreciate the warm ambiance and the friendly staff who are always on hand to ensure everything runs smoothly. And if you’re visiting on a weekend, don’t worry about a long wait; the efficiency of the team guarantees a swift seating experience, so you can dive into your meal sooner rather than later.

Whether you’re seated at the main dining area or enjoying a casual bite at the bar with a Mary’s Special (a delicious 10 oz bunless burger topped with fried onions and mushrooms, as David S. can attest), Steve's Sizzling Steaks crafts a memorable dining experience that invites you to dine with friends and family alike.

So next time you’re in New Jersey and craving a steak experience that goes beyond just food, make your way to Steve's Sizzling Steaks. With great flavor, incredible dishes, and a lively atmosphere, it’s a destination that promises to keep you coming back for more.

Contact them at (201) 438-9677 or visit their location at 620 State Rt 17, Carlstadt, NJ 07072. Experience the sizzle!

START YOUR REVIEW OF Steve's Sizzling Steaks
chris k.
chris k.

Great steak. Great flavor. The Maggie sauce is incredible, highly recommend the filet it was cooked perfect and was super tender. Fairly priced. A little old inside but as long as the food is good and the place is clean I don't mind at all. The service is great they get everything out fast. Weekends are super busy but they get you a table quick. Highly recommend.

Debbie C.
Debbie C.

Everything was fantastic! We had the filet mignon and it was the best I ever had. I love the look of the place, and the wait staff was so helpful and attentive. This was the best steak I have EVER had!!!

David S.
David S.

Enjoyed a Mary's Special at the bar with 2 beers. Mary's Special is a 10 oz bunless burger with fried onions and mushrooms. I enjoyed the atmosphere and efficient service.

Sean C.
Sean C.

We had a fun enjoyable meal. Good steaks and fries. We will be back! Got there early and had drinks at side bar. Friendly bartender who put game on TV for us. Good service, always someone stopping by table. Crimms

Kevin B.
Kevin B.

Hands down, one of the best steak places in Jersey, actually everything on the menu is great, burgers you can't beat. Definitely put it on your to go places

Randi P.
Randi P.

Very cute local joint with good food, but it is not worth all the hype. It could've been a little better. The coconut shrimp was overcooked. The crab cake was a very small portion and needed a garlic aïoli or wasabi sauce instead of cocktail sauce ,the filet mignon was good. The broccoli was very good. The cream spinach was a little too creamy for my friends. The Service was but could've been better.

Chris A.
Chris A.

I LOVE places like "The Triple S"! Family owned for it's 86 years in the business. Opened in an era when people didn't come close to dining out as much as we do now. Finding a niche amongst the super expensive chains ( ala "R-th's C-ris Steakhouse, etc) that charge you for everything but the napkins. Super casual (T-shirt, shorts? sure!) Very friendly, attentive staff. Plenty of parking. I haven't eaten here in decades and am so glad we all went back recently. The atmosphere is like an old hunting lodge ( 2 bars with 3 dining rooms) filled with mounted trophy game, tin signs, kitschy items, and signed sports memorabilia. Great for family dining of all ages. Plenty of TVs to catch a game. THE MENU..........since it's really about the food...... Small menu. Mostly steaks and a few burgers. A pork chop. fish n chips. Salads. French onion soup. A few sides: mushrooms, onion rings, french fries, creamed spinach....That's about it. ( No bake or mash potatoes) IMO the small menu has been perfected. The steaks are great! They have a preparation called "Sizzlin" where the main ingredient has a Maggi Seasoning taste. It's been around for over 100 years old. Its a little salty, but has an immense, distinctive flavor that has a large following. ( Menu states they can prepare it "non-Sizzlin" but you have to try it.) They do make current, fun cocktails like a mango margarita or espresso martini or you can just have a beer. The prices are excellent compared to any other steak house. It may not be the greatest steak in NJ, but it's damn good at a great price, and laid back. I think everyone should go to Steve's to see a part of Bergen County restaurant history. That being said I'll be going more often.

Peter T.
Peter T.

So Peggy and I are back in the area. Liberty Landing. OK maybe that's not the area but it's close enough to Steve's Sizzling Stake that we're going to make a trip. I used to come here in the 80s and 90s. I was a programmer For many of the cities in New Jersey. I asked a question to one of the police officers at Paramus New Jersey. I said, where can I get the best stake? If you want the best steak in the area it's Steve sizzling steak on route 17 about 5 miles from here. First trip down I wasn't disappointed. I still have fond memories of sitting at that bar. Ambience if you look up the word ambience is defined by Steves Sizzling Stake. Now granted, this all started before the Internet was the thing. And I have dropped in a time or two since I left the area. Close for me as anything less than two hours and I'll be there. Maybe three hours I'm not sure how long it's going to take the day for us to go from Liberty Landing to Steve sizzling Stake. My go to order? I still remember it like it was yesterday. Peters recipe for the perfect meal at Steve's. 1. Bring a friend or two for the experience should be shared. 2. Pull up to the bar. 3. Order your favorite beer for the occasion. My choice: Heineken 4. Don't look at the menu, Act like you're regular. The staff will spoil you either way. 5. Order the filet mignon, med rare. 6. It comes with stake fries, 7. Order the sautéed mushrooms. 8. Now a side of sautéed onions. 9. They will include a salad.* 10. Sit back and enjoy your beverage. 11. Enjoy the ambiance wait for your meal. Last point, when the meal is served. You will notice you can build a shish kebab on your fork for the perfect bite. Yum Yum. What you don't realize as I write this and I'm not there as it was several years ago. It's very hard to write this out and not be there. I just checked the map. It's a bit optimistic but it's only a half hour to 45 minutes from liberty Landing. Who knows maybe I'll be able to sneak two trips in;-) Can't wait.